Sunday, 13 October 2013

htet revised result formula

HTET LEVEL1 ME PASS HUE KAITHAL K STUDENTS
Kaithal 1000047 SHAKTI SINGH 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000064 HARI OM 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000175 MINAKSHI 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000277 MOHAN KUMAR 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000280 DILBAG SINGH 84 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000308 NEELAM RANI 103 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000356 SEEMA DEVI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000365 SANJAY KUMAR 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000416 MANJU 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000459 KARAN SINGH 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000746 GURNAM SINGH 89 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000825 JYOTI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000842 SHWETA 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1000917 NEELAM DEVI 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001011 RAMESH KUMAR 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001054 MONIKA 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001100 PARYAG SAINI 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001199 MEENA 100 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001210 AMAN KUMAR 88 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001232 SHIVANI 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001336 SANJEEV KUMAR 87 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001342 SURAJ BHAN 87 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001369 PROMILA DEVI 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001393 DEVI DYAL 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001454 SANGEETA RANI 84 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001547 PREM LATA 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001572 ANU 111 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001586 MANISHA JANOT 86 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001592 SUNITA DEVI 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001597 RAJ KUMAR 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1001824 AFSAR SINGH 85 QUALIFIEDBOARD OF SCHOOL EDUCATION HARYANA, BHIWANI
Revised Result : HTET 2012-13 LEVEL-1
District Roll No. Name Marks Result
Kaithal 1001840 MAHENDERO DEVI 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1002207 RINKESH KUMAR 87 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1002216 MUKESH KUMAR 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1002936 JASMER SINGH 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1003043 RAJIV KUMAR 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1003318 JASPAL KAUR 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1003642 JASWANT 98 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1003779 JASWANT 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1004100 SEEMA RANI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1004205 RAVI 86 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1004321 MOHAN LAL 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1004598 SHISHAN RAM 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1004604 ANKIT DHIMAN 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1004713 JANKI MALIK 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1004796 ANJALI SHARMA 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1004964 RITU RANI 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1005061 POONAM RANI 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1005385 AKANKSHA SARNA 100 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1005404 TARSEM CHAND 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1005473 SUKHDEV 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1005506 SHAMSHER SINGH 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1005779 SUMAN DEVI 87 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006095 POONAM RANI 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006160 ANU 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006196 MEENA MAAN 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006230 AJAY KUMAR 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006267 AMANDEEP KAUR 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006558 NITESH SHARMA 102 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006592 JAI PAL 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006762 NARESH PAL 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006782 SONIYA DEVI 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006841 ASHOK KUMAR 104 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006883 POOJA DEVI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1006934 ASHOK KUMAR 89 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1007071 POOJA RANI 90 QUALIFIEDBOARD OF SCHOOL EDUCATION HARYANA, BHIWANI
Revised Result : HTET 2012-13 LEVEL-1
District Roll No. Name Marks Result
Kaithal 1007172 GEETU RANI 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1007947 DILBAG SINGH 107 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1008019 PARVEEN KUMAR 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1008331 SEEMA 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1008874 RAJ KISHOR 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1008902 SAMRITI SHARMA 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1009064 PARDDEP KUAMR 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1009336 MONIKA 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1009346 KIRAN BALA 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1009804 KAVITA DEVI 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1009874 SONIA 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1009949 AMIT KUMAR 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1010331 SUKANYA 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1010499 SONIA 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1010820 SUSHIL MUWAL 84 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1010852 ANIL KUMAR 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1011352 AARTI 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1011416 SANDEEP KUMAR 101 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1011431 NARESH KUMAR 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1011627 SUMAN KUMARI 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1011733 ASHIM KUMAR 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1011984 HARDEEP KUMAR 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012023 MANJEET DEVI 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012029 RAJESH KUMAR 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012052 POOJA RANI 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012060 LAKHMIR SINGH PATLAN 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012065 SEEMA RANI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012102 AJAY MALIK 87 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012183 ANGREJ KHAN 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012195 POONAM RANI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012221 REENA DEVI 100 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012299 MANOJ KUMAR 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012634 JOGINDER PAL SINGH 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012681 KULDEEP SINGH 100 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1012758 KRISHAN LAL 92 QUALIFIEDBOARD OF SCHOOL EDUCATION HARYANA, BHIWANI
Revised Result : HTET 2012-13 LEVEL-1
District Roll No. Name Marks Result
Kaithal 1012828 SUBINA DEVI 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1075905 MALKEET KAUR 87 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1077580 SHAKSHI KATARIA 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1077608 SUDESH BALA 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1077640 SANJEEV KUMAR 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1077666 RAJINDER KUMAR 103 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1077796 YASHPAL SHARMA 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1077880 SONU 99 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1077891 SEEMA DEVI 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1077917 SURESH KUMAR 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1077991 RAJESH KUMAR 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1077997 SUSHIL 102 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078107 RAMDIYA 88 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078149 CHARAN SINGH 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078264 JAIBHAGWAN 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078275 SUBHASH CHAND 88 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078382 SUNIL KUMAR 89 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078402 KARAM SINGH 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078407 SANJEEV KUMAR 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078437 SATNAM SINGH 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078464 NARENDER SINGH 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078466 RAMESH KUMAR 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078471 SUSHIL KHATKAR 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078482 KULDEEP SINGH 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078561 DHARAM PAL 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078577 SAPNA RANI 83 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078627 PINKI RANI 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078881 REETU DEVI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078921 SEEMA RANI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078982 RAHUL KUMAR 84 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1078986 SEEMA 103 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079013 SURENDER KUMAR 100 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079026 PARVEEN KUMAR 86 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079075 ANITA 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079105 SUSHMA 97 QUALIFIEDBOARD OF SCHOOL EDUCATION HARYANA, BHIWANI
Revised Result : HTET 2012-13 LEVEL-1
District Roll No. Name Marks Result
Kaithal 1079284 BALRAJ SINGH 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079366 MANIK 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079452 SHAMSHER SINGH 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079501 VIKAS KUMAR 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079637 SONALI RAHEJA 99 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079654 REENA DEVI 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079788 SUSHMA DEVI 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079837 RENU DEVI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079900 SANDEEP 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1079990 RUCHI SHARMA 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080036 KIRAN GROVER 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080050 MONIKA DEVI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080109 SAVITA RANI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080114 RANBIR SINGH 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080205 KUSUM 98 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080292 SHEELA DEVI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080295 BIMLA RANI 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080297 GURMUKH SINGH 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080373 SANJU KUMAR 100 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080375 SONIA 99 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080519 BALRAM 83 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080547 PRABHJOT SINGH 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080582 SHWETA 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080589 DIVYA MADAAN 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080655 KUSHUM 101 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080689 RINKU KUMAR 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080727 RITU DEVI 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080736 SUNITA RANI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080749 PREETY RANI 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080834 MANJU DEVI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080860 RAKHI RANI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080906 RAMESH BANWALA 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1080934 GURMAIL SINGH 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081045 EKTA DEVI 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081160 PINKI RANI 91 QUALIFIEDBOARD OF SCHOOL EDUCATION HARYANA, BHIWANI
Revised Result : HTET 2012-13 LEVEL-1
District Roll No. Name Marks Result
Kaithal 1081211 RITA 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081421 RINKU 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081499 MANOJ KUMAR 89 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081759 POONAM 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081857 KULDEEP 84 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081878 ANNU 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081956 MANJEET KUMAR 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081994 LOKESH 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081996 BIMLA DEVI 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1081999 SANDEEP 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082014 SANDEEP BIDHAN 96 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082076 KRISHAN PAL 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082095 SHILPA RANI 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082125 ANU DEVI 83 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082214 SESSION 88 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082305 POOJA RANI 98 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082315 POOJA 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082344 PARVEEN MOUN 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082365 MAMTA DEVI 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082380 NIRENDER KUMARI 99 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082409 DEV RAJ SINGH 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082593 MOHIT KUMAR 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082691 SONIA 100 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082692 POONAM RANI 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082751 SONU 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082756 MOHIT 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082760 TRILOCHAN 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082765 NISHA DEVI 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082775 SONIA 84 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082789 AMIT KUMAR 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082850 NEELAM 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082916 NEELAM 99 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1082984 SANDEEP KUMAR 84 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083154 SHIVKESH 103 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083161 MANISHA RANI 92 QUALIFIEDBOARD OF SCHOOL EDUCATION HARYANA, BHIWANI
Revised Result : HTET 2012-13 LEVEL-1
District Roll No. Name Marks Result
Kaithal 1083162 POOJA DEVI 99 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083301 KAMLESH RANI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083355 NANHI DEVI 103 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083388 SUGANDHA 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083552 RAJ BALA 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083562 SONIA 88 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083708 URVESHE 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083731 PARVEEN 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083749 PRAHLAD 84 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083794 NEETO RANI 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083805 NARESH KUMAR 105 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083830 SUMAN 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083879 MANJU BANSAL 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083917 POONAM SHARMA 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083931 REENA DEVI 88 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083938 PARAMJIT 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083986 SANDEEP SAREEN 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1083999 SURINDER PAL 87 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084014 SAWAN KUMAR 84 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084134 ROOMA 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084202 POONAM RANI 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084222 RAJESH SINGH 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084297 SAVITA DEVI 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084327 PIYUSH SARDANA 88 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084387 SAROJ BALA 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084529 DEEPA 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084535 SUKHVINDER KUMAR 102 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084599 GURPREET SINGH 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084624 SUSHILA RANI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084732 RAJESH KUMAR 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084751 KOMAL CHUGH 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084764 AARTI DEVI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084767 PARVEEN KUMAR 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084790 VEENA RANI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084835 ANCHAL DEVI 90 QUALIFIEDBOARD OF SCHOOL EDUCATION HARYANA, BHIWANI
Revised Result : HTET 2012-13 LEVEL-1
District Roll No. Name Marks Result
Kaithal 1084838 MEENA DEVI 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084856 SANDEEP KUMAR 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084908 KRISHAN KUMAR 86 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1084919 BHUPENDER GOYAL 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085108 GEETA RANI 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085196 POONAM DEVI 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085197 NAVEEN KUMAR 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085233 RITU RANI 83 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085272 JAGWANTI MATHUR 83 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085300 MAMTA RANI 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085360 REETU 97 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085493 RITA DEVI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085621 AMANDEEP KAUR 88 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085867 SUNIL KUMAR 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085873 BALJEET SINGH 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085874 NASIB SINGH 107 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085888 NARESH KUMAR 100 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085904 KUSUM DEVI 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085911 MONIKA SETHI 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1085995 MAHABIR SINGH 98 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1086065 SATISH KUMAR 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1086093 SUCHIN KUMAR 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1086103 POOJA DEVI 85 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1086178 VINOD KUMAR 83 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1086219 RITU SHARMA 95 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1086338 NEELAM RANI 98 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1086390 SATISH KUMAR 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1086435 DEEPMALA 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1106981 MEENAXI DEVI 90 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1107198 RAM MEHAR 87 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1107243 ANIL KUMAR 106 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1107274 HOSIYAR SINGH 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1107416 GURBAJ SINGH 110 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1107430 AMARJIT SINGH 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1107449 SHAMSHER SINGH 93 QUALIFIEDBOARD OF SCHOOL EDUCATION HARYANA, BHIWANI
Revised Result : HTET 2012-13 LEVEL-1
District Roll No. Name Marks Result
Kaithal 1107646 SAHDEV SINGH 91 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1107716 KULDEEP SINGH 92 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1107768 NARENDER SINGH 98 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1107813 MANJEET DEVI 100 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1107998 MEENAKSHI. 94 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1108025 KAVITA DEVI 93 QUALIFIED
Kaithal 1108101 SANJEEV KUMAR 104 QUALIFIED


Thursday, 3 October 2013

BUNCHING CASE Status of Appeal COCP-2453/2013 in Punjab & Haryana High

BUNCHING CASE  
Status of Appeal COCP-2453/2013 in Punjab & Haryana High



BUNCHING CASE
Status of CIVIL ORIGINAL COONTEMPT PETITION 2453 of 2013 

MAHENDER SINGH AND ORS Vs. SURINA RAJAN AND ORS

Pet's Adv. : UMESH NARANG

Next Date of Hearing : Wednesday, December 04, 2013



BUNCHING DECISION 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
Date of Decision : 3.11.2012
CWP No. 18438 of 2010
Subhash Chander and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 13408 of 2010
Chandi Ram and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 20307 of 2010
Ashok Vashisth and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 824 of 2011
Naresh Kumar and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and another ..... Respondent(s)CWP No. 18438 of 2010 and connected cases -2-
CWP No. 3856 of 2011
Satbir Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 4343 of 2011
Gayatri and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 4347 of 2011
Manju Khurana and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 6750 of 2011
Krishan Kumar and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 7034 of 2011
Mahesh Chander and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)CWP No. 18438 of 2010 and connected cases -3-
CWP No. 7663 of 2011
Ramesh Kumar and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 8180 of 2011
Subhash Chander and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 10072 of 2011
Rajbir Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 11471 of 2011
Somvir Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 11689 of 2011
Sukh Pal Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)CWP No. 18438 of 2010 and connected cases -4-
CWP No. 11770 of 2011
Chander Parkash and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 12431 of 2011
Pawan Kumar and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 13066 of 2011
Satvir Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 14669 of 2011
Sanjay Kumar and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 15882 of 2011
Yudhbir Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)CWP No. 18438 of 2010 and connected cases -5-
CWP No. 17033 of 2011
Rajesh Kumar Yadav and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 18184 of 2011
Jai Kanwar and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 18352 of 2011
Raj Kumar and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 21003 of 2011
Sarjeet Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 616 of 2012
Kulvender Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)CWP No. 18438 of 2010 and connected cases -6-
CWP No. 3101 of 2012
Monika and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 3898 of 2012
Umed Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 6992 of 2012
Sanjay and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 7978 of 2012
Jagdish Chander Verma and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 10363 of 2012
Vijender Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)CWP No. 18438 of 2010 and connected cases -7-
CWP No. 15170 of 2012
Rajender Singh ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 16062 of 2012
Ranvir Singh and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 17949 of 2012
Seema and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CWP No. 21256 of 2012
Kishan Lal and others ..... Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Haryana and others ..... Respondent(s)
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH
Present:- Mr. S.K. Tamak, Advocate, (in CWP No. 18438 of 2010)
Mr. Umesh Narang, Advocate,
(in CWPs No. 20307 of 2010 and 824, 11770, 14669, 15882,
17033, 18184 of 2011 and 616, 3898, 7978, 16062 of 2012)CWP No. 18438 of 2010 and connected cases -8-
Mr. Vivek Arora, Advocate,
(in CWPs No. 3856, 6750, 7034, 7663, 8180, 10072, 11471,
11689, 12431, 13066 of 2011)
Mr. S.K. Yadav, Advocate, (in CWP No. 18352 of 2011)
Mr. N.S. Shekhawat, Advocate, (in CWP No. 21003 of 2011)
Mr. S.K. Verma, Advocate, (in CWP No. 15170 of 2012)
Mr. Sandeep Kotla, Advocate,
(in CWPs No. 3101, 6992 17949 of 2012)
Mr. S.K. Redhu, Advocate,
(in CWPs No. 4343, 4347 of 2011 and 10363, 21256 of 2012)
for the petitioners.
Mr. Harish Rathee, Senior DAG Haryana.
AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH, J.
By this order, I propose to decide Civil Writ Petitions No. 18438,
20307, 13408 of 2010 and 824, 3856, 4343, 4347, 6750, 7034, 7663, 8180,
10072, 11471, 11689, 11770, 12431, 13066, 14669, 15882, 17033, 18184
18352, 21003 of 2011 and 616, 3101, 3898, 6992, 7978, 10363, 15170,
16062, 17949, 21256 of 2012, as common questions of facts and law are
involved in these cases which have been taken up together as per the request
and on the consent of the counsel for the parties. For brevity, the facts are
taken from CWP No. 18438 of 2010.
Petitioners in these cases have approached this Court, impugning
the order dated 14.6.2010 (Annexure-P-4), issued by the Government of
Haryana, Department of Finance, interpreting Note 2 below Rule 7 of the
Haryana Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008 (in short 'HCS(RP) Rules,
2008') and Note 2 below Rule 18 of the Haryana Civil Services (Assured
Career Progression) Rules, 2008 (in short 'HCS(ACP) Rules, 2008'), whereby
under Clause III under the heading 'Interpretation', it has been stated that the
proviso attached with the rules ibid would not be applicable in cases where the
pre-revised pay scale of the post has been upgraded as indicated in Part-B of
the 1
st Schedule of the HCS(RP) Rules, 2008 and in column 4 of Schedule-ICWP No. 18438 of 2010 and connected cases -9-
Part-I of the HCS(ACP) Rules, 2008, as the case may be, on the ground that
this interpretation is alien to the statutory Rules, framed under Article 309 of
the Constitution of India and through executive/administration instructions,
the statutory Rules cannot be amended, altered or modified and such action of
the respondents is violative of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
the case of State of Haryana Versus Shamsher Jang Bahadur and others, 1972
SLR 441 and further that the recovery cannot be effected from the petitioners
as pay fixation had been done by the respondents on their own due to misinterpretation of the Rules. There are no allegations of mis-representation or
fraud played by the petitioners and thus, the claim of the petitioners for no
recovery is covered by the Full Bench judgment of this Court in Budh Ram
and others Versus State of Haryana and others, 2009(3) PLR 511. Reliance
has also been placed upon a Division Bench judgment of this Court in CWP
No. 18601 of 2006 titled as Om Parkash and others Versus State of Haryana
and others, decided on 10.4.2008, wherein a similar situation had arisen under
the Haryana Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 1998 and Haryana Civil
Services (Assured Career Progression) Rules, 1998, where again admissible
bunching in the revised grades were initially granted but on a clarification
issued by the Government of Haryana, the same was withdrawn which was
challenged and the said challenge was upheld by this Court, holding the
petitioners entitled to the grant of increment and the explanation issued by the
Government of Haryana, to be violative of the statutory Rules and thus, not
sustainable.
Reply to the writ petition has been filed wherein it has been stated
that the benefit of bunching was not applicable in those cases where the pay
scale of an employee was revised by the Government in pre-revised scales